HMRC refuses to stand down on £470k giant marshmallows case

  • Employment Tribunal
tribunal

Peninsula Team,

(Last updated )

After losing a £470,000 VAT case at the Upper Tribunal over whether giant marshmallows are confectionery, HMRC is taking the fight to the Court of Appeal

Giant marshmallow manufacturer, Innovative Bites, has been on the mind of HMRC for quite some time and it will not be dropping the case after losing out at both the First Tier Tribunal (FTT) and the Upper Tribunal. 

HMRC has now been given the go-ahead to take the dispute to the Court of Appeal although a date has not been set for the hearing.

Both tribunals found the consumable was not a confectionary item as it was intended to be roasted over a fire, therefore making it exempt from the usual 20% VAT. 

The placement in supermarkets also came into question, as they were mostly sold on a seasonal basis within the barbeque section.

What training is needed for food safety?

Get instant, expert answers to your HR questions...

Ask Brainbox
0800 158 2313Speak to an expert 24/7

HMRC did not feel this way, issuing demands for VAT amounting to £472,928 in for 2015 to 2019.

Glyn Edwards, VAT Director at MHA said: ‘We all thought this was the end of the giant marshmallows tax debate, but HMRC have decided to appeal again in the hope of finally persuading the tax authorities that size isn’t everything. 

‘More seriously the general public might question whether this is the best use of taxpayer’s money when we all know that making any sense of the VAT dividing lines on food has defeated the best legal minds for decades.’

Visit BrAInbox today where you can find answers to questions like Is it a legal requirement to wear a beard net in a food business?

Related articles

  • tribs

    Blog

    New Rules on Tribunal Time Limits and Right to Work Checks Become Law

    From 1 October 2026, two significant legal changes under the Employment Rights Act 2025 came into force. These changes affect employment tribunal claim time limits and the scope of right to work checks.

    Peninsula Logo
    Peninsula Team Peninsula Team
    • Employment Tribunal
  • tribs

    Blog

    What impact will the extension of employment tribunal time limits have on employers?

    From 1 October 2026, the employment tribunal claims landscape is changing. From that date, employees will have an extra three months (six months in total) to bring a wide range of claims against their employer – that’s extra time to decide whether or not to bring a claim, to get advice, gather evidence and try to come to a settlement.

    Peninsula Logo
    Peninsula Team Peninsula Team
    • Employment Tribunal
  • tribunal pile

    Blog

    Employment Tribunal backlog reaches record level as claims continue to rise

    Employment Tribunal cases are continuing to increase, while the number of claims being completed is falling, according to Ministry of Justice (MoJ) statistics for April to June 2026.

    Peninsula Logo
    Peninsula Team Peninsula Team
    • Employment Tribunal
Award-winning services

Take the first step towards a safer business. Answer a few questions about your HR and Health & Safety management and we’ll direct you to the support you need

Contact us
0800 158 2313Speak to an expert 24/7